Debunking the Myth: Potatoes Are Empty Calories?

Written by Tim Skwiat

Potatoes Are Empty Calories?

Have you been avoiding white potatoes because they’re fattening? Have you been (mis)led to believe potatoes are empty calories? Are potatoes really as bad as you’ve been told? Or, are taters actually a pretty awesome food? A food that many have mistakenly overlooked and eliminated?

Over the past 20+ years, potatoes have received a steady stream of hate mail. They’ve shouldered a mentionable portion of the blame for contributing to obesity and its associated health complications. This has led to the humble spud being demonized. Many people have concluded potatoes are nothing more than empty calories. And because of this, the average potato consumption has dropped by over 40% over the past 40+ years.1 (In hindsight, perhaps that’s clear evidence that we’re ignorant of something our predecessors were quite privy to.)

Let me say this in no uncertain terms: potatoes have been wrongly vilified. In fact, potatoes have been swept under the rug unfairly alongside a category of vegetables scientific experts consider “a forgotten source of nutrients.”2 Here’s why potatoes aren’t as evil as you may have been led to believe.

Nutrient Density

If you say potatoes are empty calories, what you’re saying is that potatoes provide NO nutrients. After all, by definition, the term “empty calories” simply means “calories derived from a food containing no nutrients.” And when it comes to the lowly spud, you couldn’t be more wrong.

This ONE food burns 350 calories (eat it today)

For every 1000 calories of this food that you eat, your body will automatically burn 350 calories. That means you get 350 FREE calories just by eating this one food. There’s no other food on the planet that can claim that! What food is it? You’ll be shocked to find out (and it’s absolutely delicious!)…

==> Burn 350 calories today just by eating this one superfood

Sure, potatoes are rich in carbohydrates, which are often misunderstood and wrongly disparaged as a group. Yet potatoes are also a concentrated source of vitamin C as well as dietary fiber and potassium. And these are nutrients that have routinely been designated as “shortfall nutrients” and “nutrients of concern” in the Dietary Guidelines for Americans. (That is, we don’t get nearly enough of them.)

As far as fiber goes, most people barely get half of what’s recommended. That’s a shame considering that fiber is an all-star nutrient that can beneficially impact blood sugar management, heart health, weight management, and of course, digestive health. Unlike most vegetables, which contain mostly insoluble fiber, potatoes are particularly high in soluble fiber, which is known to lower cholesterol and is associated with less belly fat.2–4

And when it comes to potassium, which plays key roles in heart, bone, and kidney health, most people are drastically undernourished. In fact, only about 2 – 3% of Americans get enough. Guess what? Per serving, potatoes contain more potassium than any other vegetable. Heck, a potato contains more potassium than a banana—more than three times more, in fact (with 1,553 mg to 422 mg).

There’s even more to potatoes, as they contain appreciable amounts of magnesium, phosphorus, iron, zinc, and vitamin B6.

If you still think potatoes are empty calories, the counterargument isn’t yet complete. Oh, and speaking of which, potatoes contain high-quality, complete protein. Granted, potatoes aren’t a great source of protein by any means. However, the protein quality of potatoes is higher than that of any other regularly consumed plant protein (e.g., legumes). In fact, the quality (in terms of digestibility and amino acid content) of protein in potatoes rivals that of eggs, which is often regarded as a “gold standard” protein source.2

And despite their white color, potatoes are rich in phytochemicals, many of which function as antioxidants. For example, potatoes contain substantial amounts of phenolics, including flavonoids (quercetin and kaempferol), phenolic acids (gallic acid, chlorogenic acid, and caffeic acid), which help fight free radicals and manage oxidative stress among other health benefits.5, 6 In fact, many would argue that it’s in the phytonutrient content of fruits and vegetables where their “superpowers” lie.

Editor’s Note: 8 Healthy Foods that Cause Flab

With all that in mind, it’s no wonder that populations (e.g., civilizations in the Andes) have not only survived but thrived on potatoes alone, but there’s still more…

Resistant Starch

While potatoes contain a variety of key nutrients, one that really stands out is resistant starch, which is a very unique type of carbohydrate that we’ve talked about extensively. Without getting too thick into the weeds, here’s a laundry list of benefits associated with resistant starch, which is aptly named because it “escapes” digestion:6

  • Increases metabolic rate and energy expenditure
  • Reduces the caloric density of food
  • Decreases the glycemic response to a meal
  • Reduces the insulin response to a meal
  • Improves insulin sensitivity
  • Increases satiety or satisfaction
  • Reduces hunger
  • Decreases food intake
  • Increases fat burning
  • Decreases fat storage
  • Preserves calorie-burning muscle mass
  • Promotes weight loss
  • Enhances laxation
  • Increases the uptake of minerals (e.g., calcium)

Another perk of resistant starch is that it acts as a “prebiotic” fiber. Because it’s not digested in the small intestine, it passes along to the colon where it is fermented by gut bacteria. That’s a good thing—a really good thing. For instance, one of the byproducts of this fermentation process (i.e., butyrate) helps promote a healthy inflammatory response and supports a healthy intestinal lining. And get this, it stimulates the release of appetite-crushing hormones.

Supercharge Your Immune System with Pro-X10

Promote Bowel Regularity, Improve the Healthy Bacteria in the Gut and Support Intestinal Health With ProX10!

==> Get Pro-X10 20% OFF + 2 Free Reports (Special Offer)

Raw potatoes are naturally high in amylose, which is a “resistant” starch. Cooking, however, increases the digestibility of the starch. In other words, cooked potatoes are much lower in resistant starch than raw potatoes. Get this, though. Cooked potatoes that have been cooled once again increases the resistant starch content of potatoes.

Still stuck in the mindset that potatoes are empty calories? Well, there’s even a bit more ammo in the spud gun.

Satiety

Even though potatoes are often considered a high-calorie food, they provide less than 1 calorie per gram (by weight). This makes them a low-energy-dense food (LEDF). Of course, there are preparation methods that dramatically increase the energy density of potatoes (ahem, French fries), which we’ll get into momentarily.

For now, what you need to know is that when you eat more LEDF (other examples include fruits and vegetables), you can enjoy more food (volume) with fewer calories. That’s key because one of the most important factors in making you feel full and satisfied (i.e., satiety) and cueing you to stop eating is food volume. Diets high in LEDF typically result in greater satiety and lower caloric intake.4, 6,7, 8

Speaking of satiety, which some have referred to as the “new diet weapon” or “the fullness factor,” Dr. Susanna Holt and her colleagues conducted a study where they determined the “satiety index” of 38 common foods, including potatoes, a variety of fruits, several high-protein foods, oatmeal, rice, pasta, breakfast cereals, and more. Boiled potatoes blew the competition out of the water, scoring 44% higher on the satiety index than any other food!8

Having said all that, most of you know that potatoes are rarely eaten by themselves…

Preparation Methods

So, let’s talk about the ol’ elephant in the room: preparation. This can certainly be an explanation for the notion that potatoes are empty calories. According to the United States Department of Agriculture, OVER HALF of the “potatoes” consumed by the average person come in the form of French fries and potato chips.

And if I had to guess, of the remaining portion that’s made up of “fresh,” unprocessed, whole potatoes, I’d speculate that a pretty hefty chunk of that is eaten as loaded or twice baked potatoes, mashed potatoes, hash browns, potatoes au gratin, scalloped potatoes… I think you get my point.

Most people’s ideas of potatoes are a far cry from just the humble ol’ spud. And that, my friend, is a big reason why many have been misled to believe potatoes are empty calories.

For instance, a plain baked potato contains 100 calories while a “loaded” baked potato contains at least FOUR TIMES that many calories. And, that’s probably a gross underestimate given that most restaurant-style potatoes are the size of your head. Meanwhile, an equivalent portion of potato chips packs nearly SIX TIMES as many calories as a plain spud. I think you can see where I’m going with this.

vegetable-chart

Glycemic Index

Besides being deep-fried and slathered with cheese, sour cream, mayo, ketchup, and other calorie-dense additives, another argument that potatoes are empty calories hinges on their glycemic index (GI). The GI refers to a food’s effect on blood sugar levels. While potatoes are commonly considered a high GI food, a distinction that’s often associated with poor health outcomes, there are several problems with this scapegoat:

  • The GI ignores nutrient and energy density. In the case of the former, potatoes have a high nutrient density and low energy density, which are both highly desirable. Contrast that with sugar, for instance, which has a low nutrient density and high energy density (a good example of “empty calories”).
  • The GI is based on consumption of a single food in isolation, not as part of a mixed meal. I don’t know many people who eat potatoes (routinely) by themselves. They’re usually part of a meal that includes other foods providing some protein, fat, and even fiber, which can all reduce the GI of a meal.
  • The GI is calculated based on consuming 50 grams of carbohydrate from potatoes, which is roughly equivalent to two baking potatoes. That’s a lot of potatoes. And, remember, potatoes are quite filling by themselves, let alone as part of a mixed meal. In other words, it’s not that common for folks to consume a similar amount of REAL potatoes in one sitting.
  • Even if the GI of individual foods did matter, there is tremendous variation in the GI values of potatoes, depending on the cultivar and preparation. For instance, raw and cold potatoes have lower GI scores (presumably due to their resistant starch content).

Finally, if you don’t want to take my word for it, then maybe you’ll believe a review study where researchers scrutinized the GI issue with potatoes by pointing out that taters:1

  • Have a high nutrient-to-energy density ratio (fundamentally disproving that potatoes are empty calories).
  • Are low in energy density compared to other carbohydrate sources.
  • Contribute to early satiation (feeling fuller sooner).
  • Lower food/caloric intake.

In other words, the researchers concluded that, when applied to potatoes, relying on the GI leads to premature and possibly counterproductive dietary advice. I agree.

How to Promote Increased Insulin Sensitivity

Promote increased insulin sensitivity and boost fat burning power with the synergistic blend of 5 unique, hard-to-come-by ingredients in IC-5.

Special Offer: Get IC-5 up to 14% OFF + 2 Free Reports

Potatoes Are Empty Calories? The Take-Home Points:

  • Simply put, it’s nonsensical to say potatoes are empty calories, which means “calories derived from a food containing no nutrients.” You can make an argument for sugar providing empty calories but NOT potatoes.
  • In fact, a panel of scientific experts convened by Purdue University delegated potatoes as “a forgotten source of nutrients.”
  • Potatoes have a high nutrient density and low energy density.
  • Among their many nutrients, potatoes provide significant amounts of potassium and fiber, two common nutrient deficiencies with key health benefits.
  • Raw potatoes and potatoes that have been cooked and then cooled contain significant amounts of resistant starch, which is associated with a laundry list of benefits.
  • Even though they’re not a great source, potatoes are one of the best plant-based sources of high-quality protein.
  • Have you eaten any REAL potatoes lately? If so, you know they are incredibly filling and satisfying. In fact, researchers have shown they have the highest satiety value of any food tested.
  • If you think potatoes are empty calories because they have a high glycemic index, it’s time to re-think your position. The GI is virtually meaningless, particularly when it comes to potatoes.
  • All that said, potatoes can be a vehicle for excess calories; however, the position that potatoes are empty calories is fundamentally wrong.

Eat potatoes- Avoid fat storage (4 proven methods):

At the link below, we are GIVING AWAY a brand new free report that details their top 4 “sneaky” tricks to AVOID storing carbs as fat, including the EASIEST carb trick EVER that — believe it or not — lowers blood sugar and accelerates fat loss in as little as 45 seconds flat!

Download the entire report in just a few seconds here:

==> 4 Tricks to AVOID Storing Carbs as Fat

BioTrust Nutrition- Share on Social

Share To:

More From Tim Skwiat

References

  • Are bananas good for you?
  • Anderson GH, Soeandy CD, Smith CE. White vegetables: glycemia and satiety. Adv Nutr Int Rev J. 2013;4(3):356S-367S. doi:10.3945/an.112.003509.
  • Slavin JL. Position of the American Dietetic Association: Health implications of dietary fiber. J Am Diet Assoc. 2008;108(10):1716-1731.
  • Hairston KG, Vitolins MZ, Norris JM, Anderson AM, Hanley AJ, Wagenknecht LE. Lifestyle factors and 5-year abdominal fat accumulation in a minority cohort: the IRAS Family Study. Obes Silver Spring Md. 2012;20(2):421-427. doi:10.1038/oby.2011.171.
  • King JC, Slavin JL. White potatoes, human health, and dietary guidance. Adv Nutr. 2013;4(3):393S-401S. doi:10.3945/an.112.003525.
  • Weaver C, Marr ET. White vegetables: a forgotten source of nutrients: Purdue Roundtable Executive Summary. Adv Nutr. 2013;4(3):318S-326S. doi:10.3945/an.112.003566.
  • Higgins JA. Resistant starch and energy balance: impact on weight loss and maintenance. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2014;54(9):1158-1166. doi:10.1080/10408398.2011.629352.
  • Rolls BJ. The relationship between dietary energy density and energy intake. Physiol Behav. 2009;97(5):609-615. doi:10.1016/j.physbeh.2009.03.011.
  • Holt SH, Miller JC, Petocz P, Farmakalidis E. A satiety index of common foods. Eur J Clin Nutr. 1995;49(9):675-690.
  • The Top Foods That Burn Belly Fat
  • esther

    I heard a doctor Pridecan, wrong spelling mention that eggplant, tomatoes and potatoes were not good for artherites.(spelling again). What do you think about that assumption?

    • Hi Esther,

      Thanks so much for stopping by and for sharing this question with us. Is there any chance that you have any additional information (such as a link) that we can look further into this claim? I’d be curious to get a better understanding for the context and nature of the rationale behind the suggestion.

      For now, I’ll defer to the Arthritis Foundation®, which has this to say in its article titled Arthritis Food Myths:

      Myth: Nightshade Vegetables Aggravate Arthritis

      Science. Tomatoes, potatoes, eggplants and peppers are just some of the nightshade vegetables that contain the chemical solanine, which some have branded a culprit in arthritis pain. But no formal research has ever confirmed the claim, and the vegetables contain essential nutrients. In fact, a study in the Journal of Nutrition in 2011 showed yellow and purple potatoes lowered blood markers for inflammation in healthy men.

      Bottom Line. People with arthritis may benefit from nightshades, although some people may have sensitivities to certain vegetables.”

      Of course, individuals are as unique as fingerprints, and along those lines, it’s always best to pay close attention to your personal responses to foods and build your diet around those that help you feel your best. I hope this helps, Esther!

  • Dr. Chenga

    The text seems credible. However we are not told about its source. Did any body conduct any studies to back up these claims?

    • Hi Dr. Chenga,

      Thanks so much for your vote of confidence; I appreciate your endorsement. As far as sources/studies, please see the References section above. If you have any additional questions or concerns, please don’t hesitate to share them here on the blog. I’ll be happy address them.

      Thank you, Dr. Chenga!

  • Betty Braswell

    I’m from a long back ground of potato farmers . Most of them eat potatoes , white or red 3 times a day and for snacks . Most of them have lived past 85years old , still have very sharp minds and bodies . A special lady I know will soon have her 98 birthday and still does all her own house work , drives herself to church and different errands . This special lady how ever does not smoke or drink alcohol , so the bad potato rap is crap . At 65 I still eat potatoes quite frequently as I have all my life . My last blood test was great , even the cholesteral and tri gylerides are great . I do not smoke . I do, have a glass of wine at night , and I do limit my intake of meats , Though a quality steak is so good with my potatoes

  • arshloch

    Potatoes in many forms ARE GOOD. We are goaded into eating nasty tasting garbage by nasty people, Mich anyone? If the food tastes good it must be bad for you is the common theme of the ‘we are smarter than you’ crowd. As the old saying goes, “a pox on their house”. If it tastes good, eat it. If it tastes like crap it probably is so EAT UP and ENJOY.